I have to disagree with a lot of guys on this forum. I have some great friends. Friends who would have my back over women all day (except obviously their wives and family). I have a buddy who's wife is still friends with my ex-wife. There's no love gained there. He was, is, and always has been loyal to me.
It's true, as usual and as I get older, the fringe friends I see less and care about less. As I spend more time being productive, my available time is less, so I spend accordingly.
I suppose I look at them like my brothers. I don't always hang out with my brothers. I may only see them every so often. But me and my friends went through very formative college years together, living together and figuring out life.
- Not emotionally reactionary. I could easily tell my buddy he's being a fucking moron, and he'd probably laugh at it. Sports is a good test of this. I've played many a sports with my friends (golf, basketball, tackle football (back in my 20s), beer pong, darts, volleyball, fighting, etc).
- See the humor in life. My friend is telling me how his wife is having these weird bazaar episodes and going to neurologists to try to figure it out, but in the midst of the conversation we can make a joke here and there about it. (would never make those comments in front of her)
- Has his own life, motivations, work, goals, etc. I don't want to see my friends every day, every week...every other week is completely sufficient. Every month is fine. Of course, I have people I see more often than that, but it's not usually a function of better friendships, more simply activity.
- Gotta be able to give each other shit.
Given what I've read when scanning this thread, this might suck to hear, but ...Besides my close friends I have in mind as I type the above, I have pretty damn good friends in a few different social circles...even friends I've made in the last couple years. And my close friends have a few other friends in social circles. What I'm saying is, guys who have good friends are guys who people want to be friends with. Be a guy who guys want to be friends with. Which, based on what I just wrote, seems impossible. I suspect it's not impossible, any more than turning your life around is impossible.
I suspect there are some factors that normally make the "friends guy" described above. For you sensitive types, it's not to say if you don't have one or more of these, that you aren't a friends guy, or can't be a friends guy, I just suspect these would pop up on a multi regression analysis if it could be measured:
- Came from an intact family
- Strong dad, or at least not a pushover loser type
- Had brothers, or played sports
- Played sports. Lots of sports.
- If not sports (because I know there are non-sports types out there), did something where there was objective measurement of outcome, failure, competitiveness, etc. Ego deaths are important early on.
- Aren't addicted to drugs or alcohol (I've known cool friends guys who dropped off quickly with substance abuse. See my point 2 below on therapy. Don't let substances be your therapy. Let therapy be your therapy.)
- Maintain a physical lifestyle (keep moving, stay active)
My advice would be a couple things.
1. Start doing jujitsu, or at least some very physical sport. I started jujitsu over two years ago and have made a couple really good friends from it. What I like about it (and with Jocko's blessing)...time spent on the mat makes you better, more than any other sport I've done. Athleticism is less important than simply putting in the time.
2. Therapy. This just means ramble on about yourself and your life, with someone there to hit you back with good questions. Find a good guy psychologist, and or go to group therapy. It always seems like guys who aren't friends guys have sometimes have some deep seated resentment, anxiety, or something that needs to be expressed (I have some of this as well, and therapy helps a lot). (Also, I know psychologists get a bad rap, but I suspect there are more guy psychs out there who are decent psychologists if they get the right patient.)
Sorry for the rambling post, but I hopefully it helps one of you guys who are soured to the idea of good friends. I have a soft spot in my heart for lonely men. Seems there are too many of them out there.
Edit: One huge factor is not being needy, and this may offer you guys insight as to the "can't find best friends" problem. When I think of my tightest friendships, if all of a sudden we never spoke with one another again, it wouldn't kill us. It would suck. It sucked when I heard he was going to be moving away. I would mourn it (no tears unless at his funeral). But I have my life. I have my own shit together. That's why therapy is important. Don't depend on your friend for emotional support.
Edit 2: You can become a better friends guy. I'm a lot better friends guy than I was when I was in my 20s.