I think this debate is missing some important context.
What we've all observed is a disturbing trend: the mating game in the USA seems to favor dysfunction. As Roosh said:
Quote: (01-31-2012 11:33 PM)Rooshv Wrote:
I’m slowly coming to the conclusion that something is wrong with a culture if the women explicitly prefer alpha males. It makes illogical sense from a biological and humanitarian standpoint that a woman would go after men who will not provide or take care of them. Consider that women in America are mindlessly rushing to be used as cum buckets, which is being further encouraged by the media and Hollywood that makes fun of beta men for being boring, dopey, or unromantic.
Roosh is right, something is definitely up. But what could it be?
Refer back to a thread I started earlier this month regarding
the mental health of the average American, particularly the American female.
The thread title and the first article linked show that, on the whole, around a quarter of American women are mentally ill. This represents a significant jump over men (whose percentage of mentally ill is significantly lower).
What this means: one out of every four women you meet will be off mentally.
This is merely an introductory conclusion-things become much more interesting when you break this down by age, as later posts in the thread (cibo uses some charts and statistics to break it down further
here) make clear.
![[Image: attachment.jpg4511]](https://rooshvforum.network/attachments/attachment.jpg4511)
(again, credit to
cibo for making these)
A quarter of ALL American women are mentally ill, but there is much variation by generation. Older women (who we can suspect grew up slightly more sane times) have rates of illness at roughly half of what we're used to from young girls now. When you go down to talk about young women in the 18-21 range, and you're looking at a
nearly 40% rate of reported illness.
In other words:
nearly HALF of the 18-21 year old women you run into day to day are not alright upstairs. Those are only official, reported numbers-we are not counting the legions of women who, either shy or fearing ostracization, will not report their status and go undiagnosed for periods of time (with some never seeking treatment).
It is likely that the actual, total rate of illness for girls in the 18-25 range (the one we guys, young and old, tend pursue the most) is close to 50%, and almost certainly over 40%. This is by far the highest rate in the developed world, making the USA a fairly unique case.
We've also all seen how the dynamic Roosh outlined (female obsession with becoming cumbuckets for distant men and female hatred for more laidback/respectful dudes) is also most common among younger girls. Younger girls just so happen to be the craziest ones in our society.
What I'm positing here is that there is a strong correlation between mental health and dysfunctional mate preference. American women are more susceptible to these loud, rude, dismissive, aggressive and seemingly insane fratboy/bet/thug/jersey-shore and just all around asshole mating tactics from guys because they're actually significantly crazier than other women across the world (younger American girls even more so). There is no method to their madness and they really cannot be reasoned with about it either-they're too far gone.
Bottomline: We are seeing crazy female mate choice because many of our females
actually are crazy. Simple as that.
Roissy-type tactics are built for women like this (who I suspect are particularly common in places like DC), and will work wonders on them. They won't be needed for many other women (ex: Poles, Scandinavians) simply because those women are more mentally stable on average.