Quote: (10-28-2015 02:49 PM)AnonymousBosch Wrote:
Harry Potter is an interesting case. I see the magic as just window dressing for what's just a classic English Education book series: it's Enid Blyton with wizards. Strip the tale down to the core - what the Antagnoist and Protagonist wants - and you have this:
It's the tale of two boys becoming men.
One is terrified of death and tries to uses magic to cheat it.
One accepts death is the price he must pay to protect those he loves, and welcomes it, then discovers love is the most powerful magic of all.
Interesting. I got a strong damsel-in-distress storyline vibe from Harry Potter, and always read Harry as being the manifestation of Rowling and Voldemort to be that of one of her exes.
Edit - Sorry for the thread derailment
<Spoilers, just in case>
Severe
Just like Cinderella, Harry (has a lot of potential) but is mistreated early on.
Then suddenly, magic happens and he is catapulted into a very special social position -- and is connected to everyone socially cool -- The Boy who Lived, Headmaster's pet, Hagrid's best friend, James and Lily's son, Sirius's (aka old bad boy who's really not bad just misunderstood and really really cool) grandson, Lupin and Tonks, "youngest seeker", goes into the "cool" house, random people ogle/come up to him, even the centaurs know who he is, without him having done anything on his own. Sounds like the everyday beautiful woman's life.
Poor orphan then gets de facto acceptance into a large family (Weasleys), where he's privy to more secrets than anyone within the family. Even at Hogwarts, the dude gossips and knows more than most people (map, invisibility cloak, polyjuice potions, hiding in trees, getting the house elves to snoop). And when he doesn't know, he resorts to snooping and rationalizing.
Also, all this time, everyone except the "selfish" Slytherins are ever ready to protect him. McGonagall, Dumbledore, Lupin, Hagrid, Firenze, even a fucking house elf (who he rescued out of the kindness of his heart)...in the final book ALL OF HOGWARTS (except the slytherins) and a few people from the Order of the Phoenix come in to protect him.
And so many pussy passes its ridiculous.
Hatched a dragon? Go with Hagrid to the forest.
Attacked a troll? 50 points to Gryffindor.
Not of legal age to play Quidditch? Change the rules.
Attacked Neville? 10 points to Neville.
Sectumsempra'd Malfoy and he almost died? Detention or something.
Stole shit from Gringotts? Joyride on a dragon.
Smashed car into the whomping willow? Warning.
Bunked lectures? Didn't get enough grades in "Potions"? Thats k, change the potions professor so the new guy'll accept your lousy grades for Aurorship.
Voldemort Avada Kedavras him? Wands connect and save him.
Starting with his parents up until the last book everyone keeps saving Potter, including the creepy Snape.
And then, when Voldemort calls him out in front of everyone, he walks like a martyr into death's arms just to save everyone else...
Contrast this with Voldy.
Comes from a "royal" family but orphaned and lousy family history.
Works his way up through the world through hard work, charm, intelligence.
Ambitious enough to become the best wizard and willing to do the dirty work.
Exhibits many dark triad traits. Inspires a cult following.
And of course, "part of him" is in Harry.
What does Harry have that Voldy doesn't?
Not superior skill, or intelligence or wealth, that would be blasphemous.
Love. Thats the only difference between them.
Voldemort doesnt understand the "power of love". And thats why he cant be saved.
So Harry lets Voldemort kill himself and they both get closure. Then he goes to the land of the dead where he and his gay friend direct snark at voldemort's tiny unsalveable image (micropenis cliches?)
After some chitchat Harry comes back and kills the big bad V --- not by the killing spell obviously, because hes only trying to defend himself.
V kills himself when the curse rebounds, and Harry's victory is complete.
He basks in the attention of his family and orbiters as he stands over the crushed, dead superbad alpha male figure (isnt this what most women would love their exes to look like, alpha or not?).