Hi.
Here's my hair datasheet for what it's worth:
I have been using Minoxidil (Regaine foam) twice daily for around 10 months along with Alpecin caffeine shampoo.
Some personal opinions and home truths (I am not a doctor, so just speaking from my own experience):
The caffeine shampoo is probably mumbo jumbo in my opinion. It appears to me that the Alpecin gives a 'matt' rather than a squeaky 'gloss' effect to my hair which makes it look thicker. This is a disingenuous attempt by the manufacturer to give the appearance that it is working. You could probably get the same thickening effect from using a conditioner. Nonetheless I use it every day, it isn't expensive and it might be helping so why not...
The Regaine has improved my hair marginally by only about 10-15% with no side effects nor massive shedding which I believe is about the best you can expect (i.e. i'm not overwhelmed with the amount of regrowth). There are several things about Minoxidil that I think I should mention though:
1. I believe the main flaw with Minoxidil is that it only works if it is in CONSTANT contact with the scalp which is why they tell you to apply twice per day. The manufacturers don't seem to want to address this point and it is not really mentioned anywhere. So if you put it on and then sweat it off at the gym or forget to apply it religiously it isn't going to work. So apply it RELIGIOUSLY AND LIBERALLY and massage it in thoroughly.
2. It works VERY slowly... I noticed nothing WHATSOEVER for at least the first 6 months, and I had my barber take a picture of the top of my head every time he cut it (to his amusement). Incidentally he STILL maintains it hasn't really done anything ( I disagree with him, hence my 10-15% improvement estimation) but he's a grumpy git and balding himself
3. The foam is not as good as the dropper, I am sure of this because the problem with the foam is that it is inconsistent in the amount of Minox it delivers. On different days the foam smells different or feels less viscous (in spit of shaking) so it simply isn't a consistent dosage. However, the dropper is too oily and I couldn't put up with how greasy it made my hair and scalp.
4. Similarly to the Alpecin, the foam attaches itself to your hair and makes it look thicker by default. Again, a disingenuous attempt by the manufacturer to give the impression it is working.
5. I was not that bald to start with (just general thinning with a patch at the back), and I believe this is the main reason the Minoxidil has worked (albeit not dramatically). The simple fact is if you leave it too late your follicles go from simply being dormant to being totally dead (hence the shiny bald effect as the skin grows over the dead follicles) and they will NEVER grow back. So if you have a bit of a bald patch START NOW DON'T WAIT!
6. Reading online, a lot of people seem to experience extreme shedding at the start, get scared and then stop. This is the WORST thing you can possibly do in my opinion. I think if you get a load of hair falling out when you start using Minox this is in fact the BEST sign that you are sensitive to the chemical and will have a good regrowth subsequently. I did not get a noticeable shedding at the start which is probably why my regrowth has been slow and fairly insignificant.
7. My receding hairline has continued to recede Minoxidil will have no effect on this it can only work on the crown. Only solution is a hair transplant.
Incidentally out of curiosity, I bought a mini selection box of the 'Toppix' hair fibers more for a laugh than anything else (i.e. hair in a can) and was quite astonished by how good it was. It helped that one of the colours was a perfect match for my own colour, and I would really recommend it for those who don't want to use chemicals. The trick is to apply hair spray after you have shaken the stuff on your head, that way it stays on overnight. I will re-visit this as an option if my hair loss resumes...
What is 100% certain is that my hair has not fallen out anymore in the past year and to be honest I'm absolutely elated and intend to continue to use the Regaine and the Alpecin.
Once I have done a year on this stuff perhaps I will come back to the thread and post pictures of the top of my head and YOU members can be the judge