I think you still had a shot until your last line. "Too bad because I liked you" almost sounds to me like "say a few more things and I'll be convinced." You sounded butt hurt. This is a scenario where I would just lie, I mean you're only 1 inch off.
I don't think trolling more helps in these scenarios. It comes across as insecure. Flipping the script when she said you answer first is pretty funny.
I don't think trolling more helps in these scenarios. It comes across as insecure. Flipping the script when she said you answer first is pretty funny.